'Right to appeal': International Financial Institutions and accountability –
on the way to an independent compliance and appeal mechanism for the European Investment Bank
Organised by CEE Bankwatch Network in cooperation with Friends of the Earth Europe, Friends of the Earth International, Global Transparency Initiative, Bank Information Center, Campagna per la Riforma della Banca Mondiale, WEED, Urgewald, Les Amis de la Terre
Thursday, 30 November 2006, Brussels, Eurovillage, 80 Boulevard Charlemagne - 1000 Brussels, BELGIUM
The governance and accountability of international financial institutions (IFIs) continues to suffer a democratic deficit that ultimately undermines the IFIs’ effectiveness, credibility and legitimacy. One important element of accountability is the right to appeal for those impacted by IFI activities. This conference, organised by CEE Bankwatch Network and other cooperating NGOs on 30 November 2006, discussed how an independent appeal and compliance mechanism could operationalise such a right. Also in attendance were speakers and participants from the EIB and other IFIs, the EU institutions, independent researchers, NGOs and the media.
The conference was divided into four panels and covered:
- An overview of important issues for IFI accountability;
- Existing mechanisms to ensure accountability, specifically at the European Investment Bank;
- The necessary ‘standards framework’ for financial institutions; and
- Elements of proper independent accountability mechanisms
The central point of discussion focused on concrete steps for the European Investment Bank, as one of the world´s largest public financial institutions to increase its accountability by operationalising the right for people to appeal against activities it finances.
|
Biographies of speakers
List of organizers
View a photo gallery of the event
Panel I:
Why the accountability of financial institutions is important? Need for accountability in the context of democracy deficiency
9:10-10:30
Chair: Magda Stoczkiewicz, CEE Bankwatch Network
Dr. Maartje van Putten, former member Inspection Panel World Bank and former MEP
MEP Alain Lipietz, Member of the European Parliament
David Barnden, Center for Human Rights and Environment (CEDHA)
Panel II: What are the existing accountability mechanisms on the EU level to keep the EIB accountable?
11:00-12:30
Chair: James Barnes, NGO consultant
Dr. Ludwig Krämer, Professor of European environmental law, University of Bremen & University College London, presentation based on the background paper
Peter Maertens, Inspector General, European Investment Bank
Ian Harden, Secretary General, European Ombudsman
Panel III: Standards' framework for EIB operations (international standards/conventions, EU law)
14:00-15:45
Chair: Antonio Tricarico, CRBM/Manitese
Richard Bissell, former member Inspection Panel World Bank
Steve Herz, consultant - Environmental framework, presentation based on the background paper
Tom Griffiths, Forest Peoples Programme - Social/Development framework
Gabriele Zimmer, Member of the European Parliament
Panel IV: What accountability mechanism we are looking for for the EIB?
16:00-17:45
Chair: Jennifer Kalafut, Bank Information Center
David Hunter and Natalie Bridgeman, Asst. Professor, American University Washington College of Law and Associate Attorney, presentation based on the background paper
Kunibert Raffer, Associate Professor, Dept. of Economics, University of Vienna
Martin Tanchuling, Freedom from Debt Coalition, Philippines
Noble Wadzah, Friends of the Earth Ghana
Response from Peter Maertens, EIB and other speakers, discussion
The organisers gratefully acknowledge the financial support provided by the European Commission and the Dutch Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and the Environment. |